Shoofly Pie Coffee Single Brew Cups

Rich, decadent, and unmistakably Lancaster, Shoofly Pie coffee single brew cups bring the classic flavor of Pennsylvania Dutch tradition straight to your mug. Now you can find Shoofly Pie coffee in kitchens from Philly to Wilmington, and from Manheim to Milford.

This indulgent blend features gooey molasses sweetness layered with warm vanilla, brown sugar, and a touch of baked crumb topping, creating a smooth, comforting brew inspired by one of Lancaster County’s most iconic desserts.

Shoofly Pie coffee delivers that cozy, nostalgic flavor of a homemade pie, now in convenient single-serve form. Whether you’re starting your day in Media, grabbing a quick cup in Middletown, or easing into a quiet morning in Mount Airy, it’s an easy way to enjoy a true taste of Lancaster heritage.

Conveniently packaged in a box of 12 and designed for Keurig and other single-serve brewers, these cups make it simple to savor this local favorite. No measuring, no mess, just rich, bakery-inspired flavor in every cup.

Product Details

• Roasted in small batches by Lancaster County Coffee Roasters
• Made with 100% Arabica coffee beans for a smooth, balanced flavor
• Crafted with gourmet flavorings to enhance the richness of our premium roast
• Full medium roast highlighting both our coffee and the molasses-brown sugar flavor
• Compatible with most single-brew and Keurig machines

Shoofly Pie coffee single brew cups deliver a true Lancaster County tradition, one warm, indulgent cup at a time.